|
|||||||||||||||||
|
PROGRAMS
|
| |
ABOUT US
|
| | CONTRIBUTE | | |
MEDIA ROOM |
| |
|
Introduction About the database Background Definitions Need for reliable measurements Difficulties of measurement What analysis can show Overview of findings HIGHLIGHTS Methodology Elements of Reliability Accuracy Replicability Verifiability Value as indicator FINDINGS: Wages Working Hours Child Labor Involuntary Labor Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining Abuse and Harassment Non-Discrimination Health and Safety Cross-cutting Measurements Monitoring Education about rights Grievance procedures Other About this report
|
Yardsticks
for Workers Rights: TransparencyThere are cross-cutting units of measurement other than those discussed above that current practice touches on as well, but it does so in much less detail than for any of the above. This subsection briefly and informally discusses the most significant of these other types of measurement units.For more information, the database can be searched separately for each of the subtopics mentioned below. [1] Transparency. Two key criteria for transparency, both
of which could easily be measured, are (a) whether workers are provided
with the findings of any monitors who come to the factory, either directly
or through their representatives;
[7]
and (b) whether findings are made public. The recent public disclosure of audit results
for 50 factories, provided by the Fair Labor Association for seven of
its participating companies, is an example of the latter.
[8]
Routinely checking these two criteria would
be a significant advance by itself in measurement practice. Having workers see monitors' findings
not only reduces the chance of major mistakes and omissions; it also
acts as an incentive for monitors to be thorough and accurate in the
first place.Having the public see the findings also makes
it likelier that errors and omissions will be identified, either immediately
or later as other relevant information accumulates. It also creates
similar incentives for monitors, at least among monitors who expect
to continue in the business and who expect to be competing with other
monitors for clients and credibility in the future.A system with transparency mechanisms is therefore significantly
more likely to be reliable than one without them. Feedback and Revision. The closest to a model unit of measurement
in this area, combining the themes of feedback and transparency, looks
at whether workers are aware of corrective actions that the factory
has taken in response to a monitor's findings.
[11]
When a system that is supposedly protecting
workers asks those workers if its efforts are succeeding, it is much
likelier to be operating in good faith than one that does not. Hence,
whether it makes the effort to ask is, itself, a valuable indicator. Applicable Standards. More difficult to measure are ambiguities
in the words of the policies as written, which may indicate a lack of
enforceability.Ambiguities vary by topic and are dealt with
in the sections covering specific topics that appear above. Turnover. Endnotes
[1]
On Query Page,
under the main topic "Generic Considerations," search the subtopic
"Transparency," or "Feedback and Revision," or "Applicable Standards,"
or "Other."
[2]
"Employees can see own personnel file?"[
record 1445]
[3]
"Is the company's social accountability policy accessible
to all personnel?"[record 240]
[4]
"Has the factory been subject to government inspections
during the last 24 months?"[record
201]
[5]
"What percentage of your overall monitoring work is attributed
to independent monitors?"[record 993]
[6]
"Did monitor sign confidentiality agreement with company
on audit findings?"[record 608]
[7]
On Query Page,
search subtopic "Workers Organiztions and Representatives" under main
topic "Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining." [8] See www.fairlabor.org.
[9]
"Management periodically reviews adequacy and effectiveness
of its social accountability policy and implementing system?"[
record 250]
[10]
"Are accountability measures in place to help ensure the
effectiveness of compliance efforts?"[
record 980]
[11]
"Follow up surveillance visit: are workers aware of the
remedial or preventive changes taken in response to the audit's findings?"[
record 656] "Company informs workers
about corrective measures in response to non-compliance with SA 8000?"[
record 248]
[12]
"Written policies for all code areas adopted"[
record 1547]
[13]
"Is the company's social accountability policy accessible
to all personnel?"[record 240]
[14]
"Have translated statement of principles into workers'
languages?"[record 1693]
[15]
"Stay current on labor law"[
record 1612] "Does company require its
suppliers to comply with health and safety, child labor, wage, and
hour laws of their areas?"[record
2554] "Does company require its suppliers to comply with manufacture laws of their areas?"[ record 2556] [16] "Annual turnover rate?"[record 1442] |
||||||||||||
| |
|||||||||||||